Granite or Quartz?
We'll help you figure it out.

There's no wrong answer — just the right one for how you actually live. Here's an honest comparison from a team that's seen both in thousands of Columbus kitchens.

Hardy Stone — Granite or Quartz Quiz

Granite or Quartz —
Which One Fits Your Life?

Three quick questions. We'll give you an honest recommendation based on how you actually use your kitchen.

Question 1 of 3
How would you describe your kitchen life?
We cook a lot — hot pans, heavy use, serious meals
Busy household — kids, spills, everyday chaos
Mostly light cooking, I just want it to look great
Outdoor kitchen or entertaining space
Question 2 of 3
How much upkeep are you comfortable with?
I don't mind resealing once a year — it's easy and I get natural stone
I'd rather just wipe it down and never think about sealing
Honestly, the less maintenance the better
Question 3 of 3
What matters more to you in how it looks?
I want something unique — organic patterns, one of a kind, natural
I want it to match a specific cabinet color or design direction
Clean, consistent, modern — I like things to look intentional
Rich colors, depth, warmth — natural stone has a character you can't manufacture

Granite or Quartz? We’ve Got the Perfect Fit.

Not sure which material is best for your kitchen? We’ll help you choose what fits your style, lifestyle, and budget.

Rows of large natural stone slabs, including granite and marble, displayed vertically in a warehouse, with an orange tag reading 'Crytos, Category U, Quartzite from Brazil, North Star' visible on the front slab.

Granite Countertops

  • 100% natural stone with one-of-a-kind patterns

  • Durable, heat-resistant, and perfect for kitchens or outdoor spaces

  • Available in a variety of bold or classic finishes

Stacks of white ceramic tiles with labeled tags displaying brand names and categories in a warehouse.

Quartz Countertops

  • Engineered for durability and easy maintenance

  • More consistent in color and pattern

  • A modern, low-maintenance choice that still looks high-end

Can’t decide? Visit our showroom or ask us to bring samples to your home.

Proud to Carry the Finest Stone Products from
Our Trusted Suppliers

Avani logo with stylized letter 'A' in yellow and red above the text 'avani' in lowercase black letters.
Brown MSI logo on a transparent background
Stone Mart logo with red geometric icon
Triton logo with a stylized figure and globe icon
GranTop logo with stylized orange design and the text 'GranTop Quality Granite & Quartz.'
Logo of Northstar Surfaces with a compass design and the slogan "Bring Nature Home."

Granite

You cook seriously and use your kitchen hard.

Granite handles heat better than quartz. If you're setting hot pans down without thinking, granite gives you more peace of mind.

Granite

You want something one-of-a-kind and organic.

No two granite slabs are the same. If you want a countertop that's genuinely unique, granite is the only option.— Former Customer

Granite

You have an outdoor kitchen or fireplace surround.

Granite holds up to outdoor conditions. Quartz can fade or crack in direct sunlight — granite is the right call outdoors.

Quartz

You have kids, pets, and a busy household.

Non-porous surface means spills don't soak in. No sealing, no worry. Quartz is built for real family life.

Quartz

You want low-maintenance in a bathroom vanity.

Moisture-prone spaces like bathrooms love a non-porous surface. Quartz handles water exposure without needing resealing.

Quartz

You want low-maintenance in a bathroom vanity.

Moisture-prone spaces like bathrooms love a non-porous surface. Quartz handles water exposure without needing resealing.

Frequently Asked Questions


  • Both materials are in a similar price range at Hardy Stone — typically $50–$150/sq ft installed, depending on the stone you choose. Pricing is based on the specific slab, not the material category. We'll give you a clear, no-surprise quote upfront.


  • Yes — and we recommend it. Come into our showroom at 5767 Westbourne Ave. Bring your cabinet samples. Seeing the real stone in person makes the decision a lot easier. Walk-ins welcome.

  • From the day we do your digital template to the day your countertops are installed — 5 business days. Our shop fabricates and installs everything in-house. No waiting on outside contractors.



  • That's what we're here for. Come in or schedule a free consultation. We'll look at your space, your style, and your budget and help you make the call — no pressure either way.